Hi Tim! Thanks for the feedback and the public PM ;)
Here's some advice and tips I've learned along the way with creative aps:
--You need good subject/ground separation for crisply defined shapes. As you can see in my example, most of the specular highlights are uniform in size, due to the net lighting being parallel to the focal plane. If I were to make a bigger "light sweep" with the duck in the midground, you'd see big f/g specular shapes, getting smaller and more point-light like at focal distance, then increasing in size and getting more circular as the background ramp reached vertical and maximum distance.
--With Assymetical Creative Aps, pay attention to the orientation of the disk and note that depending on focal distance, f/g or b/g specular highlights may be inverted. Chimp, and adjust as necessary!
--Look at the total cut-out section versus disk area to determine if an ap is a "small aperture" or "wide aperture." You can also set a baseline exposure for your scene with your f/8 round ap and see how your creative aps change your metered manual reading to establish a creative ap's approximate f/stop rating.
--Depth of field increases and shutter speed must be slowed for creative aps that only let a small percentage of light pass through the total disk area, obviously.
Hope this helps. Have fun experimenting and share your results!
Jack
~~~~~
~~~~~~
~~~~~~
Check out my new book! (2nd Edition now Available!)